Guests have dinner at Scrub Island Resort’s main dining room in November 2013. A US judge may soon rule to forcibly impose the resort’s plan on its creditors in order to take it out of bankruptcy.

Efforts to complete Scrub Island Resort’s bankruptcy proceeding are underway but its biggest creditor continues to object to its restructuring plan.

Guests have dinner at Scrub Island Resort’s main dining room in November 2013. A US judge may soon rule to forcibly impose the resort’s plan on its creditors in order to take it out of bankruptcy.
The resort, which remains open for business as usual, has been the focus of a bitterly contested, cross-border legal dispute since filing for bankruptcy in a Tampa, Florida court a year ago. FirstBank Puerto Rico, which financed the resort, contends that the property’s owners, Scrub Island Development Group and Scrub Island Construction Limited, an affiliated firm, owe it over $120 million in principle and interest payments.

The bank asserts that the company’s assets are worth less than $50 million. Initially, the bank attempted to foreclose on the resort via an application in Virgin Islands Commercial Court but SIDG declared bankruptcy in the US court weeks later. The resort developed a plan to restructure its debts and emerge from bankruptcy, but FirstBank has objected, asserting that the plan does not treat it fairly.

The companies’ plan called for FirstBank to receive an immediate $7.5 million cash payment and $30 million over the next five years in exchange for forgiving an estimated $84.8 million in claims against the resort.

The bank objected and has asserted that a better solution would be to bring in a new management team to run the resort. According to documents filed Friday, the resort has filed an application to “cram down” the plan, asking the Judge Michael Williamson to impose it over the bank’s objections. Mr. Williamson has said he will consider the motion.

Bank lawsuit

Additionally, on June 24, the resort filed suit against the bank alleging that a former resort executive sent dozens of emails “secretly undermining” SIDG’s interests while it was in negotiations with the bank to restructure loans. According to the suit, beginning in early 2012 bank officials repeatedly received confidential information from resort project manager James Talton and offered to pay him a commission if he was able to privately find another investor willing to buy the resort’s debt from the bank. Court documents show that the resort plans to present dozens of emails reportedly exchanged between Mr. Talton and the bank at the trial. The bank and Mr. Talton have both repeatedly denied that any improper contact occurred. The lawsuit will likely he heard in the coming months.

{fcomment}